Next year the Tigers may do something that no other AL Central team has done – field a team with a $100 million payroll. Based on the current high price contracts, the younger core reaching arbitration, and any free agent acquisitions the Tigers payroll could swell to triple digits.
Below are the contract terms for players already under contract for 2006:
Player Salary
Ordonez $15,000,000
Young $ 8,500,000
Rodriguez $ 8,000,000
Percival $ 6,000,000
Guillen $ 5,000,000
Walker $ 1,250,000
Verlander $ 900,000
------------------------
Total $44,650,000
Dmitri Young’s contract for next year is a vesting option, meaning that if accumulates enough plate appearances the option kicks in. I’m assuming that Dmitri isn’t going anywhere, and he’ll be on the payroll next year. Also, Jamie Walker has an option year that I would anticipate the Tigers would pick up. Walker’s a solid reliever and is a good value.
On the other end of the spectrum the Tigers have a number of players who have less than 3 years of service time. These players aren’t eligible for arbitration, have no leverage, and can be retained cheaply. For the purpose of this analysis, I’ll assume that each will make $400,000.
Player Salary
German $ 400,000
Spurling $ 400,000
Rodney $ 400,000
Shelton $ 400,000
Robertson $ 400,000
Logan $ 400,000
------------------------
Total $ 2,400,000
I’m not positive on the contract status of Nate Robertson and Omar Infante. Robertson saw limited action in 2002 and 2003, but I’m speculating it won’t be enough for him to qualify for arbitration.
Omar Infante on the other hand had limited time in 2002, about half a season in 2003, and full seasons in 2004 and 2005. He may qualify for arbitration so he’ll be included in the next group of players. Those are players with between 3 and 6 years of service time who are eligible for arbitration, but not eligible for free agency.
For this group of players the salary numbers are all estimates. In the case of Jeremy Bonderman and Brandon Inge, I expect the contract value to be slightly more because I anticipate the Tigers working out long term deals that will buy out the remaining arbitration years and early free agency years.
Player Salary
Bonderman $ 4,000,000
Inge $ 4,000,000
Maroth $ 2,000,000
Monroe $ 1,750,000
Infante $ 750,000
------------------------
Total $12,500,000
So far I have the Tigers estimated at a payroll of $60 million. Of course that only covers 18 players. The remaining roster places are harder to guess because currently those spots are manned by pending free agents.
Jason Johnson, Kyle Farnsworth, Placido Polanco, Rondell White, and Vance Wilson are all key contributors who aren’t under contract for next year. Collectively those players are making approximately $14 million. Whether or not the Tigers retain those players, odds are the Tigers will be paying significant money to man those spots.
Whether or not the Tigers keep Johnson, they will most likely be paying more for his spot in the rotation. If the Tigers keep Johnson, he will likely earn a raise of $1-2 million based on his performance. Alternately if the rumors are true, the Tigers could be in the hunt for AJ Burnett in which case that roster spot will cost at least $4 million more. Some cheap alternatives would include Joel Zumaya (although probably a year away yet), Sean Douglass (so far so good but two games does not a trend make), or Wil Ledezma (can he find his command?). In terms of next year, all would probably provide a dropoff based on how Johnson has been pitching thus far.
Unless the Tigers get a great offer for Polanco, or Omar Infante somehow starts ripping the ball, I expect Polanco to be back. It sounds like he loves Detroit so far, and he’s the type of hitter that the Tigers have been lacking. Plus he plays solid defense at several positions. If the Tigers resign him, I would expect it to be for approximately $5 million.
Kyle Farnsworth has pitched well enough this year for someone to pay him closers money and give him a shot. Hopefully it will be the Tigers paying him almost closers money, knowing that with an aging and injury suseceptible Troy Percival there will be probably closing opportunities. Again, barring a very desirable trade package, I’d like to see Farnsworth back with the Tigers – but it will probably cost them $3.5 million instead of the $2 million he’s currently receiving.
Vance Wilson is a veteran back-up catcher. If the Tigers don’t sign Wilson again, they will sign another veteran back-up catcher who will make approximately the same salary. The position is a wash whether or not they resign Wilson.
That leaves Rondell White. White has done what the Tigers have asked of him. He’s a great clubhouse guy, and has been one of the Tigers more consistent hitters. While he doesn’t have an arm, he gets to all the balls he’s supposed to. But, he probably won’t be back with the Tigers. This is the one position where the Tigers may go cheaper by giving the outfield spot to Curtis Granderson. Of course they could also look for a left handed slugger who costs a lot more.
If the Tigers retain Farnsworth, Polanco, and either resign Johnson or a free agent pitcher, the Tigers will then be committing at least $15 million more. That puts the Tigers at a payroll of approximately $75 million. There are still a few roster spots left, and the Tigers haven’t added that left handed bat yet. Once some filler for the 40 man roster is added, the Tigers could very well be in the $85-90 million range. So under this scenario they aren’t quite to the century mark, but they could definitely be pushing it.
Left handed slugger = Carlos Pena. No?
I might just be in a bad mood, but I’m beginning to wonder if Dmitri Young should be on this team next year. I really like him, and I think it’s great that he seems to enjoy being in Detroit, but his approach at the plate seems to be hurting the Tigers more than helping them, and 1st base/DH could be a replaceable position.
I would rather see us drop some of this payroll before the trade deadline for some decent prospects than hold to the bitter end with these guys when we all know we’re going to finish at least 15 games out of the wild card. DY and Rondell are free to go if we can get any kind of trade value for them. Johnson and Farnsworth should be traded for prospects if it looks like we aren’t going to be able to resign them (which a good GM should know)
I’m with Ian and Nolan here. If the Tigers can get something for him, maybe it’s time to move DY.
I’d hold on to Farnsworth, Nolan. Younger and cheaper than Rondell and DY, and the most effective guy in the bullpen this season. That’s nice to have a second time around, for the right money.
Hey, I’d love it if someone would take Percy.
Yeah. If we could pick up anything for DY, I’d dump him now. It sucks because I like the guy…but he looks terrible and he’s starting to find the pine frequently.
Rondell is another guy I like, and he’s performed very well–even for my fantasy team–but given the crowded outfield, I think we would be best served by dealing him at the deadline.
Farnsworth has looked good in seasons past, only to fall apart the next year–but I still think we should hold onto the guy. He looks much better than good this year.
Percival I’d trade for a sack of potatoes.
Barring injury, Dmitri Young will be with the Tigers next season. He is about 200 plate appearances away from his option year vesting. At that point, the Tigers will be paying him $8.5 million. As for trading him, his recent performance has made that difficult. The same reason that people don’t want him in Detroit is the same reason other teams won’t be interested: Too much money, too little production.
As for Pena, I’d like to see him back if there is a way to move Dmitri. I don’t want Shelton to lose at-bats. I still don’t know how good Pena is, but I know he isn’t as bad as he showed during the first two months.
The issue with Farnsworth is not if we want him around – he is obviously a great guy to have in the pen (and I think Cluck has made him better than he was when he got to Detroit) but rather if we will want to pay him what he is going to command on the free agent market. If we can ink him for a two year deal right now – great, do it. If we can’t get a deal done by the deadline I say cut him loose because the Mets (or someone like them) are just going to come along and overpay for him anyway.
And I love Rondell, I love him at the plate and I love him in the clubhouse. But business is business and if we can get value for him pre-trade deadline then pull the trigger. As someone pointed out the outfield at CoPa is crowded and that mean Rondell is odd man out this offseason (if not before).
Pena is a joke. Even if he were not a 27 year old minor leaguer he doesn’t have the power we are going to need from the 1B position if we’re going to be contending for a playoff spot.
I’d love to see a Shelton-Pena platoon, with Shelton getting a decent number of starts against righties.
The good thing about future negotiations with Farnsworth is that he isn’t accumulating those magic save cookies.
Shelton should be in the lineup full time at 1b or dh. Pena is a crapshoot at this point, they could probably get better production from a non-tender pick up. But if he smokes AAA he deserves a last chance. Young has been in a bad patch, but we know he is a better hitter than this. Trouble is he isn’t worth 8 mil even when he’s hitting well. My priority would be to give as many AB’s as possible to Shelton, give Pena a last chance, and let big D sit out enough that his option won’t vest. Not that they couldn’t hang onto him for less. Polanco was a steal and a keeper. Hope they sign him ala Guillen, before the end of the season.
This is off topic, but WHY is Bonderman not going to the
ASG, nor was he on the 32nd man ballot? The game is in DETROIT, and he’s staying home behind a guy who’s twice as old, half the pitcher, and probably 100 times the jerk. Arrrgh.
Jim! Glad you drop a line!
Any cite to document Dmitri Young’s contract status? This is the first I’ve heard that the 2006 option automatically vests depending on plate appearances.