Why is Jose Mesa still a Tiger?

Jose Mesa has been an unmitigated disaster as a Detroit Tiger. I couldn’t figure out why the Tigers signed Mesa in the first place, and for the life of me I can’t figure out why he’s still wearing the English D.

Somewhat surprisingly Mesa was actually effective in 9 of his appearances retiring the one or two batters that he needed to without incurring damage. So he can be serviceable some of the time. The problem is that when he’s bad, he is really really bad. And the real problem is that it isn’t that rare of an occurrence.

After tonight’s shellacking he has allowed 16 runs in 11 1/3 innings. He’s allowed multiple runs in 6 of his 16 appearances despite pitching more than an inning only once. This isn’t a case of a guy being left out for 3 or 4 innings at a crack. This isn’t one or two bad appearances that stain your ERA. This is a repeated pattern of bad pitching.

He has a double digit ERA. He’s allowing more than 2 base runners per inning. Opponents are hitting better than Ordonez in May against him. He simply needs to go. I don’t care who comes up to take his place. Whether it is a generic minor league free agent or a prospect, somebody has to be able to outperform him. He can’t keep games close, and he can’t pitch in mop-up duty. He provides no real value to this team.

I don’t care how far Mesa throws the ball in long toss. I don’t care what kind of physical condition he’s in. He simply hasn’t shown an ability to be able to retire major league hitters with any sort of consistency. Jim Leyland speaks of guys needing to step up and perform. That if you can’t do the job you’re out. Mesa simply can’t be counted on to do the job, and he’s hurting the team time and time again.

Mesa’s days in Detroit should be numbered, and that number should be no more than Fernando Rodney’s remaining days on the DL.

Game 53: Tigers at Indians

PREGAME: C.C. Sabathia and Justin Verlander will have a rematch from last Saturday’s Tigers loss. It’s the first of a 4 game series that is kinda important.

The Tigers had some chances against Sabathia, but couldn’t cash enough in.

The Tigers roster is one or two injuries away from being held together by duct tape so a split would be pretty cool.

Mostly I’d just like the Tigers to pick up a win here so we don’t hear about the Indians owning the Tigers.

Game Time 7:05

POSTGAME: There have been some frustrating losses this year, but this one might just trump them all. Maybe it is the freshness. Maybe it is the culmination of recent struggles. I don’t know, but I actually had to turn the game off for an hour or so. Which was really ashame because for the first 4 innings it was actually a very good game.

Sabathia was actually hittable tonight, and the Tigers even with a depleted lineup were actually able to take advantage of it. But Justin Verlander struggled with control and Jose Mesa made damn sure that the team had absolutely no shot.

While I still think it was a cheap ejection for Sheffield, he wasn’t smart. Not when the bench consists of exactly 2 players. And spazzing when your geriatric manager is trying to hold you back – just not cool.

I’ve got nothing else to say tonight. Yeah there were bright spots like Marcus Thames making the most of “regular” playing time and picking up a couple hits – one of which to the opposite field with a runner on 3rd. And Curtis Granderson hit the ball well repeatedly against lefties and layed down a sweet drag bunt. And Neifi Perez saved a run with a slick play at short. But in the mess that was the 2nd half of that game, it’s easy to either a) forget the good stuff or b) not even care.

Sneaking a peek at player of the month

Magglio Ordonez is on top of the AL in pretty much every category. With him starting slow for the first 2 weeks of the season, I figured that he had put up such gaudy numbers since that he’d be a shoo-in for AL player of the month numbers. Using the day by day database I pulled his competition for the month through the games of May 29th.

It turns out that there is quite the battle, and it could come down to the last day of the month. There are 3 players who have a real legitimate claim and their numbers are strikingly similar:

Kevin Youkilis has been the toughest out. Magglio Ordonez has hit for the most power. Mark Texeira has the least protection, as evidenced by the 4 intentional free passes and has knocked in the most runs.

It’s a player of the month honor, so it’s really not that important. I’m of course pulling for my home town guy, but it is an impressive group nonetheless.

Tigers Minor League Wrap – 5/30/07

Toledo 7 Scranton 0
Jordan Tata is back. He made the start tonight, and it was a short one as they build his arm strength up, but by all accounts successful. He went 3 innings and threw 34 pitches and allowed only a walk with no strikeouts. Ron Chiavacci “started” the back end of the game and pitched 6 scoreless innings allowing only 4 hits and 2 walks while fanning 5. Mike Hessman hits his 14th homer, a grand slam. Chris Shelton added a double and a single.

Harrisburg 4 Erie 9
Jeff Larish doubled and walked twice. Andres Torres tripled and singled. Jair Jurrjens allowed 4 runs on 9 hits, a walk, and a strikeout over 5 2/3 innings.

Lakeland 9 Tampa 2
Burke Badenhop allowed 2 runs on 3 hits and 2 walks while throwing 7 innings. Ovandy Suero had 3 hits and a walk, and no stolen bases. Wil Rhymes and Ryan Roberson also had 3 hits. Cameron Maybin was 1 for 5 with a walk.

Lansing 2 West Michigan 3
Jeff Kunkel had 2 hits to lead the offense. Scott Sizemore added a double. Jeff Gerbe started and went 5 innings allowing 2 runs on 7 hits and 4 strike outs. Randor Bierd was perfect in relief retiring all 9 hitters he faced, 4 via Ks.

Game 52: Tigers at Rays

PREGAME: The Tigers will try and take the series against the Rays. But to do so they’ll have to find success off a good pitcher. And it’s not Scott Kazimir. I know, it’s weird.

I must confess, I didn’t know anything about James Shields until I went to type this up. All his number look pretty good. He fans 7.8 per nine innings and walks only one fourth that many. He’s allowed only 59 hits in 74 1/3 innings. The only slight blemish is 9 homers which still isn’t bad. Plus he’s efficient, last through at least 7 innings in each of his last 7 starts. Who knew?

The Tigers will send out Nate Robertson who is getting torched lately. He’s allowed 37 hits over his last 4 starts spanning 20 1/3 innings and he’s walked 7 while fanning only 8. He thinks he’s figured out the problem which would be timely.

POSTGAME
: Things looked so good when the Tigers picked up 2 hits on 2 swings and ultimately plated 3 runs in the first inning. But James Shields started doing what he’s been doing all season and shut down a pretty good offense.

  • This is the first game in a while that offense was really shut down. Sure they’ve had some low run totals, but in the other games they were still hitting balls hard and getting baserunners. Tonight it was one inning of offense and 8 innings of nothing. And aside from Granderson’s triple and Thames single those were the only hard hit balls. Even in the rally they were turf hits.
  • And Shields was efficient enough that he could stick around the whole game. You’d like to see the hitters run up the pitch count, but he was throwing strikes. They just couldn’t manage solid contact.
  • Nate Robertson started off great. He was getting swings and misses and not a lot of solid contact. But then the pitch counts started running up and the baserunners started to accumulate. And again he couldn’t get out of the 6th inning.
  • Plus he allowed 2 more homers bringing his total to 5 in the last 2 games.
  • A couple of the runs came across as the result of miscues. The first was when Marcus Thames misplayed a grounder in the hole. Thames looked simply devastated on the bench after a wild pitch and a double scored the first run. Without the misplay Nate gives up 2 less hits, throws fewer pitches, and saves a run.
  • The other run Nate got himself into with a wild pickoff throw that there was nothing Thames could do about that allowed the runner to advance to 3rd.
  • Magglio’s hit streak came to an end. It’s also the first game in a while where he didn’t have a hard hit ball. Ordonez still drew a walk, but never made solid contact. This includes fouling off a couple of hittable fastballs in his first at-bat. I’m not knocking him at all and it’s only one game. I just hope he’s not slowing down because he’s been amazing to watch. Plus if Guillen is out, Ordonez probably won’t see as many good pitches.

Game Time 7:10pm

links for 2007-05-30

Game 51: Tigers at Rays

PREGAME: Minimalist post this time. Family obligations have kept me from writing the past few days. Today is me and Mrs. Billfer’s anniversary, so I won’t be witnessing the game, commenting on it, or writing about it after the fact. Probably not minor league wrap tonight either. Sorry bout that, but on occasion things trump the Tigers.

In any case, it’s Jeremy Bonderman and Casey Fossum as the Tigers try to stem a 4 game losing skid.

Game Time 7:10

Tigers Minor League Wrap – 5/28/07

Toledo 0 Scranton 2
Some guy named Roger Clemens started this one and held the offense to 2 hits. The Hens only amassed 3 total. Cory Hamman started and allowed only 1 run on 6 hits over 6 innings

Erie 5 Akron 4
Kody Kirkland homered and added a single. Erick Almonte also had 2 hits. Dallas Trahern started and allowed 4 runs on 7 hits over 6 1/3 innings. He induced 12 ground outs against only 3 flyballs.

Lakeland – DNP

Fort Wayne 5 West Michigan 11
Brennan Boesch and Scott Sizemore each picked up 4 hits and Gorkys Hernandez added 3. Duane Below needed all the help he could get giving up 5 runs on 6 hits, including 2 homers, in 5 1/3 innings.

Minors News

Matt is now a member of the working media. Way to go Matt!

Game 50: Tigers at Rays

PREGAME: The Tigers head to Tampa to try and heal from a home sweep at the hands of the Indians. The Devil Rays have a history of helping teams heal, however they aren’t the pushover they once were, at least offensively where they rank in the middle of the AL in runs scored. However, they walk in the bottom third of the league and lead all teams in strikeouts so you can pitch to them.

Chad Durbin will be doing that pitching tonight for the Tigers. Durbin has done about what you can expect and hope for from a 5th starter. He’s giving the team 5 plus inning each time up and holding the opponents to 3 or fewer runs.

The Tigers will be opposed by Edwin Jackson. Jackson posts a very solid 7.5 K/9 rate. And that’s the only positive. He’s walked 23 in 37 innings and allowed 48 hits. Of course the Tigers have had their share of struggles with struggling pitchers at times this year. Here’s hoping this isn’t one of those times.

Game Time 7:10pm

Tigers Minor League Wrap – 5/27/07

Columbus 5 Toledo 14
No shortage of offense for the Mud Hens with Ryan Raburn leading the way. He hit for the cycle. Mike Hessman nearly matched him but was a single short. David Espinosa hit his 2nd homer of the year and Chris Shelton added two hits and a walk. Yorman Bazardo allowed 1 run on 6 hits, 4 walks and 1 strikeout in 6 innings. Roma Colon making a rehab appearance allowed 2 runs on 3 hits and a walk in 1 inning of work.

Erie 3 Akron 5
A meager day for the Seawolves with only 5 hits. Eddie Bonine allowed 4 runs in 4 2/3 innings on 7 hits, 2 walks, and 2 K’s.

Palm Beach 3 Lakeland 2
Ovandy Suero had 2 hits and a walk. Surprisingly it resulted in only 1 stolen base, and 1 caught stealing. Cameron Maybin was 0 0for 3 with a walk. Eleazar Aponte pitched 6 shut out innings allowing 6 hits and 3 walks while fanning 5.

Fort Wayne 2 West Michigan 10
Brandon Timm had 3 hits, including 2 doubles. Ryan Strieby hit his 5th homer and added a single. Audy Ciriaco, James Skelton, Deik Scram, and Gorkys Hernandez all had multi-hit games as well. Angel Castro pitched 8 shutout innings allowing only 5 baserunners and striking out 3.