Gene Guidi writes in the Free Press that the Tigers might try to swing a trade with the Angels for one of their starters, Aaron Sele, Ramon Ortiz, or Jarrod Washburn. As for who the Tigers would be offering up: Craig Monroe or Brandon Inge. I’d imagine the deal would also involve one of the Tigers AA/AAA pitching prospects as well. Still, while Wasburn or Ortiz would be a great addition to the Tigers (I have no interest in Sele) I just don’t see the Angels going for something like this. The one advantage the Tigers would have is Anaheim’s motivation to dump $5-6 million off a very high payroll already. However, I’m sure there will be other takers who could offer more.

Other Stuff:
-Here is an article about pitching prospect Joel Zumaya
-There is a new baseball site called Baseball Outsiders. They have some feature writers, and they have a network of other bloggers as correspondents. DTW is the the Tigers correspondent. I’ll be linking to some of their feature content, and they’ll be linking to some of mine.

Solicitation:
Coming up in March I’m taking part in an event called Bowl For Kids Sake to benefit the Big Brothers and Big Sisters of Metropolitan Detroit. In the past I’ve never used this website to solicit funds of any sort. I’ve just written about the Tigers as a labor of love, and I’m not looking to make money. However, if you do like the content on the site, and feel so inclined to make a donation to a good cause, I’ve placed a donation button over on the right where you can sponsor me. All of the donated funds will go to Big Brothers/Sisters. I know making donations on the web is a leap of faith, but I’d encourage you to trust me. If you’re uncomfortable using Paypal, and are interested in sending a check, email me and I’ll get in touch with you with my address. Thanks in advance for any donations.

I’d planned on writing an analysis of the Tigers bullpen for this year. However, a discussion on Primer inspired this post instead. Craig Monroe was a stud against lefties last year, and a dud against righties. Can we expect the same this year?

I frequently read the Clutch Hits at Baseball Primer because they not only provide a number of links to interesting articles, but because the discussions that ensue are quite interesting. This particular thread deals with the expected platoon splits of right handed batters. Essentially, data shows that for all right handed batters the ratio of their OPS versus left handed pitchers to their OPS versus right handed pitchers is 1.09. In other words, right handed batters hit southpaws nine percent better than right handers. This makes sense and is to be expected.

Now here’s the interesting part. This is the expected ratio for all right handed batters. That is, given enough plate appearances right-handed batters will approach this average. Furthermore, there aren’t really hitters who are more adept at hitting left handers over right handers than their peers. So while some hitters hit left handed pitchers very well, those are also commonly the hitters who hit right handers better than their peers also.

If this all seems confusing, don’t worry, it is. Dodger Thoughts has done a much nicer summary than I have. But my point in bringing this up isn’t to necessarily explain it all. More I wanted to look at Craig Monroe.

Monroe’s OPS in 268AB’s against righties was .600, and against soutpaws it was .900 in 157AB’s. The resulting ratio is 1.61, or tremendously higher than the expected 1.09. If we are to believe that all right hand hitters will move towards 1.09 that means that in the coming years Monroe will either improve his performance against righties, or not perform as well against lefties (or both).

The point is that I was convinced that Monroe definitely should be starting against lefties next year over Sanchez/Higginson. While I still think he should, I just shouldn’t expect him to achieve an OPS of .968 when he does.

The larger question that will only be answered in time is whether or not Craig Monroe is closer to the .600 OPS guy, or the .968 OPS guy.

Now that Pudge mania has died down, I figured it would be a good time to take a look at the pitching staff he’ll be handling. While the Tigers offense is bound to produce more runs, will it be enough to compensate for a pitching staff that gave up 928 runs last year? This was sufficient to keep them in next to last place in the AL despite playing in Comerica Park (Texas was last with 969 runs). While the starting rotation is 80% established, we’ll have to make some guesses on who will make up the bullpen. Actually, with a pitching staff so young, it is hard to make any sort of prediction on this years performance, but I’ll give it a stab anyways.

Starters
What a difference a year makes. Last year going into spring training the Tigers had no starters. This year they have 4/5ths of the rotation identified. Jeremy Bonderman, Mike Maroth, and Nate Cornejo are the holdovers from next year. They are joined by free agent acquisition Jason Johnson. Jason Johnson will be the number one guy in the rotation. His peripherals are only okay, but that still qualifies him as the ace of the staff. Also, his peripheral stats for the last several years have moved in a pretty narrow range, so it’s reasonable to expect a similar performance again this year.

Maroth did everyone but himself a favor by making 20 game loser Brian Kingman irrelevant last year. This doesn’t make Mike Maroth a bad pitcher, but calling him average might be generous. However, this was his first full season in the majors. His strikeout, walk, and hit rates were similar to his 2002 performance when he had 21 starts. However, he gave up 34 dingers, or 1.58 per 9 innings despite being a lefty in Comerica. If Maroth is going to continue to be a starter in this league he will have to improve his home run rate. This seems plausible because in 2002 he allowed only 7 HR’s in 128 IP (or .49/9 IP).

Jeremy Bonderman made his pro debut last year, and despite some struggles, and an ERA of 5.56 he definitely showed promise. He had a stretch in June where he went 4 games without walking a batter. He also had the best strikeout rate among other Tiger starters. Another plus for Bonderman is that his defense independent ERA was .75 runs lower than his actual ERA. Considering he wasn’t old enough to buy a beer last year, there is definitely hope for him. One disturbing split is that he had serious trouble against the Twins. In 5 games (4 starts) he only lasted 16 innings, and the Twins hit .477 against him. I know this is a small sample size, but given that the Tigers and Twins battle 19 times, I’m hoping this was just a fluke.

Nate Cornejo led the team in ERA and pitching win shares despite the fact that he allowed 13.5 baserunners per 9 innings. He had a microscopically low 2.13 strikeouts per nine innings, and allowed a tremendous amount of balls in play. Cornejo has the ability to throw a ton of innings, and if he pitches well enough to stay in games, it wouldn’t surprise me to see him top 200. His inability to strikeout opposing hitters may signal that his performance and ERA may suffer next year. However, with only one full season under his belt, it’s is hard to know what a “normal ” season will be for him.

The 5th starter spot will most likely be held by quite a few different people. Those that are likely to see time include Gary Knotts, Nate Robertson, Rob Henkel, Wil Ledezma, Kenny Baugh, and possibly Preston Larrison if he can bounce back from a disappointing season at AA last year.

So this still doesn’t answer the question of what to expect from the rotation next year. Last year Tiger starters accounted for 61% of the innings pitched, which works out to about 5 1/3 innings per game. It seems reasonable to expect that with the addition of Jason Johnson, improvement from Bonderman (and probably a slightly relaxed pitch count), and my hope that Maroth can improve marginally by cutting down on his home run rate, that the Tigers starters can average 6 innings a game. Six innings per game equates to 972 innings. The table below shows my projections for innings pitched for 2004, and the pitcher’s DIPS ERA from last year. I arrived at the earned runs projection by applying last year’s dERA to my projection for IP. For the 5th starter, I used the the “replacement level” dERA from last year. Last year the Tigers starters allowed 562 ER’s in 885 IP. I’m projecting that the starters this year would allow 553 ER’s but in 972 innings.

Now there are some limitations with this analysis. I don’t really allow for any improvement by the pitchers, but given the age of the pitching staff it is hard to measure how much they will improve. Also, if the bullpen improves, the starters should be charged with fewer earner runs as well. Furthermore, this assumes that the Tigers defense is league average, which it wasn’t last year. I haven’t done any analysis yet to see if they will in fact be a better defense next year, but my gut tells me they will probably be below average as long as Sanchez is playing center. Hopefully on Monday I hope to have a similar analysis for the bullpen, and in the coming weeks I’ll be taking a closer look at the offense and defense as well. The plan is to zero in on runs allowed and runs scored projections so that I can make a moderately scientific prediction on wins and losses for the coming year.

As a point of acknowledgement, I found all the DIPS stuff at Jay Jaffe’s Futility Infielder. The other pitching stats came from a variety of sources. The starter/reliever split is courtesy of ESPN.com. The rest of the stats I had in a convenient Excel format courtesy of the TwinsGeek.

I saw a link to this on Primer and apparently there is a group of investors that want to buy the Expos and bring them to Detroit. The plan is that they would play in Tiger stadium.

Who’da figured that the 119 loss Tigers could generate this much local interest in the offseason. Granted, most of the buzz is surrounding the guy they haven’t gotten yet, but believe it or not people give a damn about this team. Attendance at Tigerfest was 11,235 which is pretty incredible considering they failed to draw that many to 14 of their home games last year.

Also surreal is the amount of support that Brandon Inge and his .198 career average has garnered. It all started when Brandon said he was as good defensively as Pudge. Inge received a lot of flack for this, which is to be expected. However, I’ll devote a couple sentences defending him. First, I’m happy to see a player speak his mind. I’m sure it was an uncomfortable situation, and Inge didn’t go looking for reporters to talk about this. Second, he may have a point. He actually threw out runner at a .364 rate last year compared to Pudge’s .333 and that was withh an extremely young and inexperienced staff holding runners on. Also, he had half as many passed balls as Pudge while catching three-quarters as many innings. Third, is that Inge has grown up with this pitching staff and knows the staffs capabilities as well as anyone, so I don’t think Pudge would have an advantage calling pitches and handling pitchers. Fourth, I don’t see anything wrong with a player that has confidence in his abilities, and notice he didn’t try to defend his offensive performance. Now what hurts Inge is that Pudge has 10 more Gold Gloves than Inge does, so his credibility in making those statements isn’t all that great. Since then, his teammates and coaches have been very vocal in support of Inge. (Just to be clear, I’m not implying that Inge is better than Pudge, or that Pudge wouldn’t be a significant upgrade. I just wanted to illuminate the fact that his comments weren’t as crazy as they first appeared. )

Meanwhile, on the Pudge front Boras and his client submitted a counterproposal on Friday, and the rumor is the contract length is still 4 years with the disparity being money.

Unfortunately there’s not any more to report on this situation.

Comerica Changes
I’ve been informed, from a reliable source in the organization that the Tigers do in fact plan to move the bull pens to the left field wasteland and fill in the current right field bullpen area with seats. The plan is to have this completed before the All-Star game. I wasn’t at Tigerfest, so I don’t know if this was talked about there as well, but I haven’t seen it published anywhere. I also don’t know any other details about how things will be layed out exactly, or more detail on the timeline.

So it has been widely reported that the Tigers have made Ivan Rodriguez a very generous offer of 4 years for $40 million and the response has been a resounding silence. Up until Wednesday, I thought this was purely a ploy by Scott Boras, but then with Pudge coming to Detroit for the physical I acutally started to believe the deal might happen. Now, without any response for the I-Rod camp I’m reverting back to ploy concept, especially considering there hasn’t been another team interested. Sure, Boras has talked about a mystery team, but nobody can figure out who this team is. Whether or not you like the Peter Gammons’s, Jayson Stark’s, Ken Rosenthals they are pretty well connected in the sport and nobody has published a hint of another team.

So what does this mean for the Tigers? Could they have done anything differently to seal this deal? I actually think the Tigers played this as well as they could have. Yes, 4 years is too long, and $40 million is too much money, but the Tigers are in a position where they need to play by a different set of rules. All they have to offer is money because they can’t sell players on a good situation. As long as 2-3 years from now we don’t start hearing how the Tigers can’t sign players because so much is invested in Rodriguez it should be okay. I like that they didn’t make a play until the market was completely dry for Pudge. I also like the fact that they tried to keep this fairly quiet, but not totally silent. The Tigers also get additional points for the timing of this “negotiation” that occured the same week that season tickets went on sale hoping to further generate buzz, which it did.

Now the other question is who is the anonymous source that released the terms of the contract? The obvious answer would be Boras to increase the bidding. However, could it be that the Tigers made the offer on Thursday, and when Pudge didn’t accept it by Friday night they leaked it to scare off other bidders (if there are other bidders)? Nobody else is going to offer those years or dollars. Sure, it might make the Tigers look bad to be spurned even though they offered the best contract, but before last week was there anybody that actually thought Pudge would sign here?

The next question is how long do the Tigers leave the offer out there?

Other Stuff
-Over on Tigerscentral there is a pretty good discussion about the impact of Pudge signing.

Sorry about the lack of posting, the flu has been making it’s way through my household (despite the whole family getting shots). I like the Guillen trade. They got something for nothing essentially. True, the Tigers lost their best bunter but I think they will survive. Now it looks like Pudge might be a real possibility. If the Tigers were to add I-Rod they would have a respectable lineup-especially if Munson and Pena can continue to develop.

CF Sanchez
2b Vina
DH Young
C Rodriguez
3B Munson
1B Pena
LF White
RF Higginson
SS Guillen

True it’s not murderer’s row, but it would be a marked improvement over a lineup full of number 7 hitters. I’m pretty sure we wouldn’t see anymore innings where 3 consecutive batters bunt.

Of course this isn’t news anymore, but with the holidays and all I didn’t get a chance to write about this pick up. It’s not a bad move, but nothing to get overly excited about it either, pretty much the same way I feel about Vina and White. I share Brian’s concerns about the fact he is 30 and hasn’t had a 200 inning season yet. In 32 starts last year he only made it out of the 7th inning 7 times. This isn’t necessarily a horrible thing in general, but the Tiger brass are targeting him for the top of the rotation and you expect your number one or two guy to be able to eat some innings. But the fact of the matter is, anybody that is going to sign with the Tigers at this point is going to have a major drawback or two.

Hope everyone enjoyed the holiday season, and Tigerfest is just a couple weeks away.

ESPN is reporting that the Tigers have signed outfielder Rondell White to a 2 year $6 million dollar deal. No word yet on Tejada. The News says the Tigers made a 5 year $50 million dollar offer, but that the sides are very far apart. I’ve got some kids to take care of now, and I’ll process this deal a little more later today hopefully.

Contingent on a physical, the Tigers have signed Fernando Vina to a two year contract for $3 million a year. While many have complained about this deal, I don’t mind it…yet. I don’t think you can really evaluate this signing until you see the other moves that the team makes this winter. If the Tigers compliment this signing with 2-3 other signings at key positions like shortstop, catcher and pitcher, then this could be worthwhile. If Vina is it, then it is a horrible move.

What this does signal is that the Tigers are willing to bring people here even if it means overspending. I know they’ve said they’d do it all along, but now they are actually doing it. It also means that free agents are willing to not only consider Detroit, but actually sign here. For that Dombrowski should be applauded.

While the Tigers did overpay, and while Vina might not be a significant offensive upgrade over Warren Morris, it is only a two year contract. I would consider signing to be a step forward (albeit a pretty darn small one). Let’s just hope there is more on the way.

The Free Press is reporting that the Tigers have made an offer to Fernando Vina. Vina is coming off an injury shortened 61 game season. However, he is a career .284 hitter with a .350 OBA. He’s 34 and made $5.3 million last year and it is believed to be a two year offer that the Tigers have made. ESPN is reporting that Vina is leaning towards signing with the Cubs. ESPN also is reporting that the Tigers are interested in Rich Aurilia should he not be offered arbitration by the Giants. The Red Sox may also be pursuing him.

With the Tigers pursuing Aurilia and Vina, it reveals a little bit about what their strategy is (or at least what I think it may be). The Tigers aren’t looking for players who will help them win a World Series. They are targeting veteran players who will help the team improve in the short term, to bridge the gap so to speak. What’s more important is that they are going after players that they feel will be tradeable. Dombrowski was yearning to trade veterans for prospects last summer, but he didn’t have the veterans to trade. His veterans weren’t good enough and made too much money for too long. If the Tigers can sign Aurilia or Vina to a short term contract, even if they have to overpay a little, they could finally have something to offer playoff contenders. Now this strategy isn’t without risk. If the Tigers do get these types of players, and then can’t trade them who do they turn to in two years to take the reins? The Tigers don’t really have any 2B or SS prospects throughout the minors. Of course this is all a bit premature because the Tigers haven’t actually signed these guys yet, and that in itself would be a major coup for Dombrowski.

In other news, Kevin Witt signed a minor league deal with St. Louis and Adam Pettyjohn inked a minor league deal with San Francisco.